More stories

  • in

    How Labour welfare vote rebellion compares to previous revolts by MPs

    Keir Starmer has suffered a serious blow after dozens of his own MPs voted against his planned welfare reforms in Parliament. The prime minister had been forced into two humiliating U-turns on the legislation in less than a week to head off a revolt that threatened to defeat his government on one of its flagship policies. But how does this compare to previous revolts by politicians? It is the largest rebellion of Sir Keir’s premiershipAccording to political scientist Professor Philip Cowley, from Queen Mary University of London, who has done a comparison of previous votes, it was the largest backbench rebellion Starmer has suffered so far. The previous record holder was earlier this month during the passage of the planning and infrastructure bill, when 16 MPs rebelled. A smaller revolt last year, over the controversial two-child benefit cap, saw a number of Labour MPs stripped of the party whip – including Jeremy Corbyn’s shadow chancellor John McDonnell.Sir Tony Blair with Sir Keir Starmer (Stefan Rousseau/PA) More

  • in

    Starmer survives by skin of his teeth – and here’s what he must do now

    Ahead of the welfare reform bill vote, a frustrated minister privately questioned the whole approach to the painful debate.“We are spending an extra £20bn on welfare [compared with the last government], we are not cutting it by £5bn but somehow everyone believes we are cutting it by £5bn,” they said. “There is clearly a problem with messaging.”Ahead of a damaging rebellion by Labour MPs on an issue which has pitted the parliamentary party against its own leadership, the comments reflect a widespread criticism of Sir Keir and many of his ministers.Nothing underlined the mess more than the dramatic late concession during the debate to postpone changes to disability reforms to try to stave off a humiliating defeat.One Labour MP put the prime minister’s problems more bluntly: “He is just bad at politics.”Keir Starmer in the Downing Street garden More

  • in

    Disabled Labour MP breaks down in tears over party’s welfare cuts

    A disabled Labour MP cried as she delivered an impassioned speech criticising her party’s welfare cuts on Tuesday, 1 July.Marie Tidball, MP for Penistone and Stocksbridge since 2024, explained that she felt compelled to join politics after the Conservatives’ series of severe spending cuts and tax increases when they were last in government.Ms Tidball, who was born with a congenital disability affecting all four limbs, condemned Labour’s proposed cuts and confirmed that she would be voting against the bill.The bill would see changes made to personal independence payment (Pip) and the health-related element of universal credit. More

  • in

    ‘Distraught’ families say they may have to homeschool SEND children if school forced to close amid VAT raid

    “Distraught” families are fighting to save a private school which faces being shut down within days amid soaring financial pressures and the government’s controversial VAT policy.One mother, 48, told The Independent she will have no choice but to homeschool her son, who has special educational needs (SEND), if Bishop Challoner School in Bromley closes as planned on Friday, the last day of this school year.Of the school’s 271 pupils, 94 have SEND, according to the Independent Schools Inspectorate’s report last year. This is around 35 per cent of students – almost double the 18 per cent of all pupils in England – according to the government’s figures for January 2024.The school said it had become an increasingly challenging environment for schools, with falling birth rates, rising living costs, and the VAT rule adding to the issues. It said other government policies – such as the increase in employers’ NI and the removal of rates relief – had contributed.Fees for the private school’s infant years started at £4,591 a term inclusive of VAT, increasing to £6,562 for secondary school pupils, with scholarships available for “outstanding achievement”.A father said it was his five-year-old’s “devastated” reaction that drove him to set up a group for the parents to join forces in efforts to save the school, out of which their fundraiser was born. At the meeting when the school’s closure was announced, he described “every parent who attended showing a huge ‘roll your sleeves up, we’re gonna fight for this school’” attitude.Stacy Long, 40, said his son, Paddy Dowling Long, attends the school. The 40-year-old father said: “He was absolutely distraught for a couple of hours. It blew me away. I couldn’t believe the attachment he showed. The fight to keep it alive has been because of his reaction.“He’s shy and refused his first day of school. To see the development they’ve done with him, educationally, socially – there had to be a fight to keep the school alive.”The government’s policy to impose 20 per cent VAT on private school fees came into effect on 1 January and draw much backlash from the sector More

  • in

    Labour welfare bill latest: Rebel MPs lash out at Starmer over ‘Dickensian’ benefit cuts ahead of vote

    Welfare U-turn will cost £2.5bn by 2030, Liz Kendall tells MPsLabour MPs have branded Sir Keir Starmer’s welfare proposals as “Dickensian”, as the prime minister prepares to face a backbench rebellion this evening.MPs are debating the second reading of the government’s welfare bill ahead of a crunch vote in the Commons this evening.The bill would see changes made to personal independence payment (Pip) and the health-related element of universal credit.With the prime minister’s authority on the line, work and pensions secretary Liz Kendall confirmed a number of concessions to cuts on Monday in an effort to head off a major rebellion by Labour backbenchers.However, dozens of Labour MPs have signed an amendment proposing to sink the legislation on Tuesday.Rachael Maskell – who tabled the amendment – called the cuts, “Dickensian”, “from a different era and a different party” as she stood in the Commons on Tuesday.“These are my constituents, my neighbours, my community, my responsibility, and I cannot cross by on the other side,” she said.MPs will vote on the amendment before voting on the second reading on the bill this evening.Pictured: Protesters gather outside parliament( More

  • in

    Small boat crossings hit record high in another blow for Starmer

    A record number of people have crossed the Channel in small boats in the first six months of this year, new figures show – despite Sir Keir Starmer’s pledge to “smash the gangs”.Just days before the prime minister marks one year in office, new data from the Home Office shows a total of 19,982 people have arrived in the UK since the start of 2025 – the highest total for this point in the year since data was first collected on migrant crossings in 2018. The prime minister has been struggling to bring down both the number of boat crossings and the amount of money spent on housing asylum seekers in hotels across the UK. But he has also faced criticism from left-wing Labour MPs and refugee charities, accusing Sir Keir of attempting to copy Reform UK’s inflammatory rhetoric. Prime Minister Sir Keir Starmer has defended his Government’s record as he faces a major revolt on welfare reforms More

  • in

    Leading rebel Rachael Maskell chokes up sharing devastating impact of welfare cuts on disabled constituent

    If you are experiencing feelings of distress and isolation, or are struggling to cope, The Samaritans offer support; you can speak to someone for free over the phone, in confidence, on 116 123 (UK and ROI), email jo@samaritans.org, or visit the Samaritans website to find details of your nearest branch.Rachael Maskell became emotional whilst describing the impact of welfare cuts on her constituent on Tuesday (1 July). The Labour MP for York Central, who put forward a second amendment rejecting the Universal Credit and Personal Independent Payment Bill, said her disabled constituent told her that “it would be better if he wasn’t here”.The bill would see changes made to personal independence payment (Pip) and the health-related element of universal credit. More

  • in

    Trans charity demands investigation into EHRC following Supreme Court ruling on gender

    A leading trans campaign group has requested an investigation into the Equality and Human Rights Commission (EHRC), claiming its conduct in the wake of the Supreme Court ruling on gender has been unlawful, The Independent can reveal.It comes after the Supreme Court ruled that trans women are not legally women under the Equality Act. TransLucent said they have submitted a formal complaint to the Global Alliance of National Human Rights Institutions (GANHRI) – the worldwide membership-based network of national human rights institutions (NHRIs)– claiming that the UK’s equalities watchdog is failing to adhere to the Paris Principles. The Paris Principles set out the minimum standards that NHRIs must meet in order to be considered credible and to operate effectively. The key pillars of the Paris Principles are pluralism, independence and effectiveness.The Supreme Court judgment has proven controversial More