More stories

  • in

    Mehdi Hasan on Kamala Harris vs Donald Trump – podcast

    It’s been a rollercoaster couple of weeks in the US election campaign. On Sunday Joe Biden announced he would not stand for re-election, before endorsing his vice-president, Kamala Harris, as the presidential candidate for the Democrats. On Monday endorsements – and money – rolled in from donors and political luminaries. Mehdi Hasan, a columnist for the Guardian US and a co-founder of the media organisation Zeteo, tells Michael Safi why despite criticising Kamala Harris in the past he is now an enthusiastic supporter of her campaign to be the next president. He explains how her entry will change the race for the White House, how Republican politicians might attack her, how her campaign may differ from Biden’s and, crucially, what he thinks of her chances of success against Donald Trump. More

  • in

    Biden calls for justice after footage released of police killing Black woman

    Joe Biden has called on Congress to pass the George Floyd Justice in Policing Act, moments after shocking police video was released showing an Illinois officer fatally shooting Sonya Massey after she called police fearing a home intruder.In his first public statement since dropping his bid for re-election, Biden said the shooting of Massey, a 36-year-old Black woman, by white Sangamon county sheriff’s deputy Sean Grayson, in her home in Springfield, after a dispute over a pot of boiling water, “reminds us that all too often Black Americans face fears for their safety in ways many of the rest of us do not”.Biden, who is recovering from Covid at his home in Delaware, said Massey, “a beloved mother, friend, daughter and young Black woman … should be alive today”.“When we call for help, all of us as Americans – regardless of who we are or where we live – should be able to do so without fearing for our lives,” he said in the statement, adding: “Sonya’s family deserves justice.”“While we wait for the case to be prosecuted, let us pray to comfort the grieving,” he continued. “Congress must pass the George Floyd Justice in Policing Act now. Our fundamental commitment to justice is at stake.”The act, known as HR-1280, addresses a range of issues in policing practices, including excessive force and racial bias and increases accountability for law enforcement misconduct. The bill was passed by the House in 2021 but stalled in the Senate.The statement came as a protest march is planned for Monday evening after police bodycam video released showed a rapidly escalating situation.Massey had been retrieving a pot of water from the stove after Grayson told her he did not want a house fire. Massey asked the officers – who visibly distanced themselves from her as she goes to handle the pot – why they moved away from her.“Where you going?” she asks them.“Away from your hot steaming water,” Grayson answers, with a laugh, before Massey responds: “Away from the hot steaming water? Oh, I’ll rebuke you in the name of Jesus.”“You better fucking not. I swear to God I’ll fucking shoot you right in your fucking face,” Grayson warns.Massey can be heard saying, “I’m sorry,” as Grayson continues to advance. “I’m sorry,” she says again as Grayson, with his gun drawn, fires three shots, killing her instantly. After the shooting another deputy said he was going to get his medical kit.“No, a head shot, dude, she’s done,” Grayson responds.Later on in the video, Grayson calls Massey “fucking crazy”.The prominent civil rights attorney Benjamin Crump, who is representing Massey’s family, previously said the video would “shock the conscience of America like the pictures of Emmett Till after he was lynched”, referring to the photograph released after Till was lynched in Mississippi in 1955.Crump also likened the video to the police killing of Laquan McDonald, who was shot 16 times in the back by police in Chicago in 2014, and to the police murder of George Floyd in 2020.“It is that senseless, that unnecessary, that unjustifiable, that unconstitutional,” Crump said at Massey’s funeral on Friday. “This video is tragic in every sense.”Grayson has been charged with three counts of first-degree murder and is being held without bond until his trial is set to begin. Springfield resident Tiara Standage told the Guardian that when she watched the George Floyd tape, “it pissed me off. When I watched this, it pissed me off even further.”Antwaun Readus Sr, a local community activist, criticized city officials for spending money on police equipment but neglecting basic community services.“They militarized the whole police department,” he said, predicting that when the police video of Massey’s death was released, “the whole country can go upside down.” More

  • in

    The Democrats must back Kamala Harris. An ‘open convention’ would be a fiasco | Ben Davis

    Joe Biden’s resignation has left the party with two clear options. The first and easiest is for the convention to be a rally for Kamala Harris as the nominee, as nearly all party conventions have been for the last 40 years. The second is to have a floor fight at the convention, with multiple candidates fighting to win over a majority of delegates.The second option is attractive for a few reasons. It creates a process for candidates to win over support from major constituencies in the party, it allows them to make their cases to the broader public much like a regular primary, and it could draw in a large audience. It is the preferred solution of many of the party’s major donors and even, according to some reporting, some of its most astute political leaders.A big open primary and contested convention, however, is still a bad idea. The party institutions and leadership should consolidate behind the vice-president and take the fight directly to Trump as soon as possible.An open nomination fight would be distracting and potentially confusing to voters when there is almost no time to spare. The first ballots will be sent out in less than two months. The Republican national convention has already happened. The minute hand is rapidly ticking.After a bruising traditional primary, parties usually have months to consolidate, mend fences and build enthusiasm. This will not be the case here. The party has already spent the last three weeks paralyzed and unable to campaign while the pressure mounted for Biden to drop out. Biden dropping out has resulted in a groundswell of enthusiasm, including a record-breaking small-dollar donation haul, and Democrats can’t waste any time capitalizing on that enthusiasm and turning it into resilient support for November.Harris is also less known by the public than most nominees would be at this stage. The convention offers an opportunity for her to define her image and make her case to the public. A winning convention would involve dozens of speakers who know her and are able to speak convincingly to her record. A floor fight would prevent that.A floor fight would also cause some structural problems. Though Harris would still be a heavy favorite, someone else winning would not be able to access the campaign’s finances, more than $100m on hand, or infrastructure, more than 1,000 staff members, and a team that has been embedded in swing states organizing and building connections for months. There is very little time to start from scratch.There is also the problem of who is pushing the primary idea of the blitz and why. Progressives in the party have noted that the main drivers behind the blitz primary are megadonors and more conservative party members who see it as a chance to install a more business-friendly candidate and clean house from the Biden administration’s more progressive economic policies and regulators. A primary entirely aimed at winning over a base of moderate party officials, they reason, could turn back the clock to a Democratic party with a more straightforwardly neoliberal policy agenda, and jettison pro-worker actors within the administration like Biden’s NLRB appointees or FTC chair Lina Khan.This would be disastrous for the party and for working class Americans. This sort of primary would not be more democratic, as proponents claim, but instead a return to the days of the smoke-filled room. Harris, at least, has a mandate from voters as the vice-president.The proponents of this blitz primary idea also don’t seem to have a real plan for how it would work, and how it could result in a strong campaign heading into November. The ideas on the table range from confused to ludicrous, like a candidate forum to attract youth voters hosted by Mr Beast, or the revealing idea for a national security forum hosted by neoconservative grandees like Condoleezza Rice. This is not a serious plan.This is not to say that the convention should be a pure coronation. With this change, there is still policy to figure out, and leaders should use their leverage. Progressives should demand action and real policy change from Harris on Palestine, and commitments on the promises Biden made in his waning days. Uncommitted delegates should agree on a single candidate to nominate, and push to gain speaking time for that candidate to represent the millions who are rightfully alienated from the administration over the issue of Gaza.That is quite different, however, from an open convention where many candidates are sincerely attempting to win from the floor, and more in line with how recent nominating conventions have worked.To win the election, Democratic leaders need to ditch the idea of a blitz primary and focus on consolidating for the general. The summer has already been too chaotic for them to add to it, and the Democratic party should reject calls from billionaire donors hoping to install their own candidate and eschew a chaotic and confusing fight. While everyone has the right to court delegates, the party should consolidate rather than forcing through some set of debates and forums between candidates with no mandate from voters.A smart party would begin moving immediately to keep momentum and project confidence and unity, rather than continuing the turmoil and chaos. The stakes are high, and there’s no time to lose.

    Ben Davis works in political data in Washington DC More

  • in

    The Guardian view on Joe Biden quitting the race: a fresh start for Democrats | Editorial

    Joe Biden’s announcement on Sunday marked the beginning of the end of an American political life filled with second acts. None was more remarkable than his defeat of Donald Trump in 2020. His acceptance that he could not do so again will burnish what his vice-president on Monday described as an “unmatched” legacy. Elected to relief rather than elation, as the man saving the US from a second Trump term, he became the president who helped it recover from the pandemic, pushed through a landmark green infrastructure package and sought to shape a fairer economy.He could now be a lame duck, beset by Republican attacks on his capacity to continue as commander-in-chief. But he could cement his record, emboldened by the certainty of departure from office. His decision to quit his re-election bid was belated, yet in sharp contrast to Mr Trump’s delusional egotism.Kamala Harris now appears as queen of the comeback. She floundered in the race for the 2020 nomination and was seen to struggle as vice-president, though few shine in that role. Yet Mr Biden has endorsed her as his successor, as have other top Democrats, including potential challengers. Not much more than 100 days before the election – and with early voting beginning in just two months – few want to snub her and take chances on a little-known alternative, especially if it complicates campaign finances.Ms Harris would not only be the first woman of colour to win a presidential nomination. She would be a 59-year-old running against an often incoherent 78-year-old; a voice of warmth against a vindictive demagogue; a former prosecutor running against a convicted criminal. A woman who has staunchly advocated abortion rights would take on the man who ensured Roe v Wade was overturned – and whose running mate has extreme views on abortion, pushing for police to have access to reproductive health records. She has been somewhat more critical of Israel over the war in Gaza than Mr Biden, perhaps shoring up progressive support. And people have regretted underestimating her: she had Mr Biden on the ropes over his attitude to segregationist senators and opposition to school integration policies in a 2019 debate, and skewered William Barr, Mr Trump’s attorney-general, in a Senate hearing.There is nonetheless a strong case for an open convention – reportedly the preference of Barack Obama and some donors. Some fear that the party is repeating the mistake it has just made with Mr Biden: ignoring qualms because it assumes it has no choice. Ms Harris is familiar to voters, unlike potential rivals, but unpopular. Polls suggest she outperforms Mr Biden in a contest with Mr Trump, but doesn’t erase the latter’s small lead – and does more poorly in battleground states. Republicans are already turning her thankless task of overseeing border issues against her, and accuse her of covering up her boss’s frailty.A contest for the nomination carries some risks – Democrats don’t want to see their nominee damaged by a bruising process – but it could generate excitement, push Mr Trump out of the limelight and produce a strong running mate. If delegates rallied behind Ms Harris, that would strengthen her bid. If another candidate proved even stronger, all the better.Democrats rightly believe that this election could prove existential for American democracy. But that hasn’t proved sufficiently persuasive for voters. Polls suggest that they want change, and were uninspired by Mr Biden’s request to let him “finish the job”. The Democratic nominee must grasp the opportunity born of his debate disaster and create the sense of a fresh start, not only for the party’s campaign, but for the US itself. More

  • in

    Kamala Harris – and Democrats – face an unprecedented task with 100 days to election

    When Joe Biden addressed the NAACP convention in Las Vegas last week, one of his biggest applause lines – a line that set off chants of “Four more years!” – was when he praised Kamala Harris as “not only a great vice-president” but someone who “could be president of the United States”.Now she has that chance.On Sunday, when the president made the extraordinary decision to end his re-election campaign, he made an equally momentous choice: to offer his “full support and endorsement” of Harris to be the Democratic nominee and take on Donald Trump in November.“It’s time to come together and beat Trump,” the 81-year-old president said. “Let’s do this.”The announcement, just weeks before the Democrats are set to formally choose their nominee at the convention in Chicago, has plunged an already tumultuous contest deeper into unchartered waters – while thrusting his would-be successor into the spotlight.“I am honored to have the president’s endorsement and my intention is to earn and win this nomination,” Harris said. “I will do everything in my power to unite the Democratic party – and unite our nation – to defeat Donald Trump and his extreme Project 2025 agenda.”With just over 100 days until the November election, the task before her is monumental and unprecedented. An assassination attempt on Trump has united Republicans behind him, and appears to have strengthened his hand as Democrats dissolved into a rancorous debate over Biden’s fitness to serve.The question of who would replace Biden has consumed Democrats and party strategists, allowing for an intense public discussion over whether Harris would be the strongest candidate to defeat Trump in November.The US-born daughter of immigrants, Harris spent much of her career as a prosecutor, before becoming California’s attorney general, overseeing the nation’s second largest justice system. In 2016, she was elected to the US Senate, becoming the first south Asian American and only the second Black woman to serve in the chamber, where she distinguished herself for asking tough questions of Trump-era political nominees.Many of Harris’s supporters say she is the obvious heir apparent to Biden. She is also the administration’s strongest messenger on abortion rights, a top issue for many voters, especially women.But her skeptics point to her failed 2019 bid for the Democratic nomination, which lacked cohesion and vision, and her shaky start to the vice-presidency, which opened her to withering Republican criticism. Some Democrats are not necessarily opposed to Harris, but believe she would benefit from an open competition – rather than a “coronation” – to prove to party skeptics, donors and voters she is the best candidate for the job.They say a fast primary campaign would showcase to the American people that Harris is best person for the job, and give would-be contenders a chance to compete – or at least debut as potential running mates.By anointing Harris, Biden has greatly tipped the scale in her favor. But it does not automatically make her the nominee.Jaime Harrison, chair of the Democratic National Committee, called the situation “unprecedented” but said the party was committed to carrying out a “transparent and orderly process”.In a remarkable change of course after weeks of infighting, Democrats rushed to throw their support behind Harris, including a wide swath of members of Congress; Hillary Clinton, the first major female presidential nominee; and some would-be opponents like Gavin Newsom, the governor of California; Pete Buttigieg, the secretary of transportation; and Gretchen Whitmer, the Michigan governor. On Monday, Joe Manchin, the one-time Democratic senator turned independent, said he had no plans to vie for the party’s presidential nomination.Harris has a handful of advantages over other potential challengers. She has been vetted at the national level and has good name recognition. As Biden’s running mate, she would also likely inherit key parts of his campaign, which includes a large war chest of donor funding and massive field operation.On Sunday, Biden’s campaign fund was renamed “Harris for President”, a filing with the Federal Elections Commission showed. As of Saturday, the campaign had nearly $96m cash on hand, according to the FEC. And donors who abandoned Biden in an effort to push him from the race could restart their contributions to a presidential campaign led by a younger candidate.Harris may also benefit from Democrats’ desperate desire to unite quickly and turn the focus back on Trump, whom they view as an existential threat to American democracy.Trump has repeatedly mocked Harris, assailing her intelligence and her laugh, while mispronouncing her first name. On Sunday, Trump called Harris “as much of a joke” as Biden, and said she had been “complicit” in covering up the president’s decline.View image in fullscreen“Harris has been the enabler-in-chief for Crooked Joe this entire time. They own each other’s records, and there is no distance between the two,” he said.The former president has a history of amplifying racist and sexist conspiracies about Harris, including a birther lie that suggested, falsely, she might be ineligible to serve as president.The independent candidate Robert F Kennedy also attacked Harris as a “war hawk” on Ukraine and China, and accused her of holding one of the “worst civil rights records of any public official”.Republicans have said they were prepared for a torrent of opposition research on Harris, stemming from her failed 2020 campaign and her years as vice-president.If the attacks ramp up, they could play on Harris’s vulnerabilities. Recent polling that considered a hypothetical matchup between Harris and Trump found her running close to or stronger than Biden nationally and in the battleground states.Like Biden, Harris is unpopular, though her approval rating has ticked up slightly in the weeks since the party began pressuring Biden to withdraw, following his disastrous debate.“She’s the most unpopular vice-president since Dan Quayle – and Dan Quayle is the most unpopular-vice president since Aaron Burr,” Frank Luntz, a pollster and consultant, said recently. Burr, remembered as the vice-president who mortally wounded Alexander Hamilton, served under Thomas Jefferson at the turn of the 19th century.Harris’s supporters say her historic nomination could help inspire and mobilize Democrats who had so far been disillusioned by their options.Santiago Mayer, executive director of the Democratic-aligned Voters of Tomorrow, said Harris’s tour of US college campuses was “incredibly well-received” and helped her understand the unique needs of young people, who polls show are disillusioned with the entire political system.“We saw the ‘Kamalove’ that gen Z feels for her and we’re incredibly excited to have a younger, more diverse face representing the incredibly successful and pro youth Biden Harris agenda,” he said, pointing to the “coconut tree” memes spreading online in an ironic but earnest show of support.At nearly every stage of her career, Harris has broken barriers, and should she win the nomination, “the nation will watch a multiracial woman compete in a presidential general election for the first time in history,” said Debbie Walsh, director of Center for American Women and Politics. “This transformative moment will forever alter how Americans view leadership in politics.”Biden’s decision to withdraw, and Harris’s commitment to seeking the presidential nomination, means the Democratic ticket is also in need of a vice-presidential candidate. Should Harris be the nominee, several names have been floated including the Arizona senator Mark Kelly, who endorsed the vice-president on Sunday, as well as the governors of Kentucky, Andy Beshear; Pennsylvania, Josh Shapiro, who also endorsed Harris; and North Carolina, Roy Cooper.Democratic groups had already organized an effort to boost Harris’s image and defend her against the Trump attacks that would have come regardless of her position on the ticket. Among them is Way to Win, a Democratic donor network that endorsed Harris.Tory Gavito, the organization’s president and co-founder, said the vice-president performed especially well with young people and voters of color, key constituencies that Democrats have struggled to excite.With Biden’s decision to pass the torch to Harris, she likened the Democratic party to an Olympic sprinter crouching at the starting line.“All this wait period has just given us that sort of kinetic energy to now run,” she said. “And I think it’s going to just un-tap a bunch of enthusiasm that gets us ready for November.”Read more about Joe Biden dropping out of the 2024 election:

    Joe Biden drops out and endorses Kamala Harris

    Democrats praise Biden and Republicans go on the offense

    Who will replace Biden? How does the process work?

    A look back at Joe Biden’s life in politics More

  • in

    ‘Oh thank God’: Democratic swing state voters feel relief after Biden drops out

    For many Democratic swing state voters, Joe Biden’s decision to drop out of the 2024 presidential election came as a relief.“Oh thank God,” said Cathy Gramze, a retired nurse who lives in the suburbs of Detroit. “My diagnosis has for a long time been that he cannot run again and I am not entirely sure that he should finish his term in office.”Gramze had worried about Biden’s fitness long before the debate. His 27 June performance merely confirmed what she had long feared. “A lot of the time he is the president we need, but some of the time he isn’t.”Kamala Harris, who Biden endorsed on Sunday and who has earned the endorsement of most prominent Democratic elected officials, “needs to be the presidential nominee”, Gramze said.For more than a year, voters across the political spectrum have been saying they feel Biden, who is 81 years old, is too old to run for re-election. Those anxieties crescendoed in the wake of his first debate with Donald Trump, in which Trump lied repeatedly about a range of issues and Biden struggled to push back or even answer questions coherently. Following the debate, more than 30 Democrats in Congress called on Biden to end his presidential campaign, with the powerful former Democratic House speaker Nancy Pelosi reportedly ratcheting up the pressure on Biden to drop out of the race last week.In the last few weeks, polling has increasingly shown Biden lagging in critical swing states, with large majorities of Democratic party voters indicating they believe he should not renew his campaign. Recent national polls also show Trump losing to the vice-president, whose path to victory, like Biden’s, will involve winning the critical states of Michigan, Wisconsin and Pennsylvania.Not only Democrats welcomed the announcement. Dan Rose, who has long supported Trump, said he was glad Biden pulled out of the race.“He doesn’t have the caliber we need in a president,” said Rose, who said he worries about the economy. Rose, who is from De Pere, Wisconsin, said he will still support Trump but felt Biden had made the right choice in ending his campaign. “The Democrats might be in a pickle now,” he added.skip past newsletter promotionafter newsletter promotionIf the Democrats are in a pickle, few grassroots party members expressed concern following Biden’s announcement.“How courageous and brave of him to do that,” said Chris Fleming, who is retired and volunteers for a group organizing rural Democratic voters in Wisconsin. This year, Fleming’s husband had $15,000 in student debt cancelled by the Biden administration – which she said left her feeling grateful for Biden. “I have nothing but respect for him,” she said.Jake Knashishu, an attorney from Decatur, Georgia, said Biden’s departure from the race “relieved, for the most part, concerns about him being able to really present himself as an effective alternative to Trump”. Biden’s withdrawal gives Democrats a better shot at Georgia, Knanishu said.He had spoken with a neighbor on Sunday who “saw Joe Biden as kind of Ruth Bader Ginsburg 2.0 – holding on and refusing to pass the torch and maintain stability”, said Knashishu. “She just feels relieved, because she knows that at least we’re not going to have that happen again.” More

  • in

    As Biden departs, Trump set to face questions over his age and acuity

    With 78-year-old Donald Trump now certain to face a Democratic candidate younger than he is, the Republican could have the tables turned on him over the questions of age and mental agility that he often sidestepped while Joe Biden was his opponent.The age gap between Trump and any of his likely Democrat opponents – Kamala Harris, 59; Michigan governor Gretchen Whitmer, 52; Pennsylvania’s Josh Shapiro, 51 – could make him the sole focus of voters’ desire for a generational handover of power.And with Biden’s often stumbling public appearances – and especially his disastrous debate – now a thing of the past, there is likely to be a fresh focus on Trump’s mental acuity and his frequently rambling, confused campaign speeches.Last month, for example, Trump got the name of his own doctor wrong. Previously he has made high-profile campaign trail gaffes, in which he seemed to think Barack Obama was still president and mistook his arch Republican rival Nikki Haley for Nancy Pelosi.Nearly 60% of US voters said last month that Biden should “definitely” or “probably” be replaced, while Trump’s favorability rating had risen to 40% since his hush-money conviction and the attempt on his life eight days ago. Harris’s favorability sits at around 39%.Biden’s departure from the ticket upends several aspects of Republican’s calculations, including that Trump the felon will now possibly have to debate Harris the former prosecutor in September – if she receives the nomination.The vice-president proved her debating skills in 2019 when she delivered a highly personal attack on Biden on the issue of race that he later described as “hurtful” and chilled relations between the Biden-Harris camps before she was named vice-president.Political commentator Anthony Michael Kreis posted on Twitter/X soon after Biden’s announcement: “I can’t believe the GOP is running an old guy for president. Yikes.”Trump’s reaction to his recent assassination attempt – pumping his fist and mouthing “Fight, fight, fight!” – has been full of vigor and helped unify his Republican party behind him and after his brush with death, he vowed to run a “unity” campaign.But that pledge dissolved on Saturday when he returned to disparaging Biden, Harris and the Democratic agenda and has been delivering his usual rants on the campaign trail, often laced with conspiracy theories and even a repeated and bizarre reference to a shark.After Biden announced he would abandon his re-election effort, Trump responded to Biden’s announcement, saying his now ex-rival was not fit to run for president and “not fit to serve”.Trump said last week he didn’t think that switching out Biden for Harris “would make much difference”, he told Bloomberg. “I would define her in a very similar [way] that I define him.”skip past newsletter promotionafter newsletter promotionA pro-Trump Super Pac accused Harris on Sunday of being “in on” a cover-up of Biden’s “mental decline”, and characterized her as the driving force behind the administration’s policies.Democratic strategist Hank Sheinkopf says that Trump’s “less than gracious” response to Biden stepping down is something Democrats will hope continues as a successor to Biden emerges. “Trump is reverting to type, Biden is out of the picture, and Trump is the only one who can seize defeat from the jaws of victory.“Without having Biden as his opponent, and calling him ‘Sleepy Joe’, who is he going to rail against? How he attacks a woman is very different but you can already tell from the way he attacked Biden on Sunday that he’s not thinking clearly. His vitriol has taken over again.“Democrats will be able to use Harris as an offensive chess piece in the suburbs of the country, women’s right to chose and reproductive freedom, and hope that Trump screws up by overreacting so they can accuse him of bring incapable of controlling himself because of his age,” Sheinkopf said, “and it becomes a different race.”Read more about Joe Biden dropping out of the 2024 election:

    Joe Biden drops out and endorses Kamala Harris

    Democrats praise Biden and Republicans go on the offense

    Who will replace Biden? How does the process work?

    A look back at Joe Biden’s life in politics More