A no-deal in Brexit trade talks at the end of the year would slow down the police and make it harder for them to catch criminals from European countries, MPs have been told.
Richard Martin, the Metropolitan Police’s lead for Brexit, said the contingencies in place to deal with disruption if a trade deal is not reached were “not as quick, or as effective” as the systems currently in place.
The deputy assistant commissioner told the Commons EU future relationship select committee on Tuesday that “instant, at your fingertips” access to EU-wide criminal databases would be lost to police on the ground.
Download the new Independent Premium app
Sharing the full story, not just the headlines
Police and judicial cooperation is one of the main stumbling blocks in EU negotiations, with matters complicated by a UK refusal to give written assurances Britain will remain a party to the European Convention on Human Rights that guarantees the rights of European citizens will be respected.
“It’s at your fingertips, it’s live time, it’s immediate. If we lose that capability, we will revert to Interpol notices which are slightly different They don’t have the full capability of SIS2 [a database],” Mr Martin told the committee.
“Our use of the European arrest warrant combined with SIS2 [a database] means that my officer, who may be in uniform stopping a car on the streets of London, can identify somebody immediately if they are may be wanted for murder in France. Or one of our other member states can immediately arrest them and put them through the extradition process.
“The worst-case scenario is my officer is left in an ambiguous position where [if] they do stop a car, they do stop somebody that’s wanted for a very serious offence. And if there are no other grounds to arrest that person there and then, they’ve got to run off to Westminster magistrates court, which is the only court in the land that can issue the warrant. So, yes, there’s a big risk that they could have abscond or disappear.”
The warning comes a day after the Home Secretary said foreign criminals would be reported under the UK’s new post-Brexit border operating model.
The government has said it wants to reach a deal with the EU by the autumn but that it would be prepared to leave the single market and customs union at the end of the year without an agreement.
While the government refers to the arrangement as an “Australia style Brexit”, the approach would in fact represent a significant upheaval of UK-EU relations overnight and is expected to cause major disruption.
The latest news on Brexit, politics and beyond direct to your inbox
“Losing access to viral security tools would represent a huge failure on the part of UK negotiators,” said Naomi Smith, chief of the pro-EU campaigning organisation Best for Britain.
1/37
Pro-Brexit supporters celebrating in Parliament Square, after the UK left the European Union on 31 January. Ending 47 years of membership
PA
2/37
Big Ben, shows the hands at eleven o’clock at night
AFP via Getty
3/37
Pro Brexit supporters attend the Brexit Day Celebration Party hosted by Leave Means Leave
Getty
4/37
Brexit Party leader Nigel Farage smiles on stage
AFP/Getty
5/37
People celebrate in Parliament Square
Reuters
6/37
A Brexit supporter celebrates during a rally in Parliament square
AP
7/37
Police form a line at Parliament Square to prevent a small group of anti-Brexit protestors from going through to the main Brexit rally
PA
8/37
Nigel Farage speaks to pro-Brexit supporters
PA
9/37
PA
10/37
JD Wetherspoon Chairman Tim Martin speaks as people wave flags
Reuters
11/37
Getty
12/37
Brexit supporters wave Union flags as they watch the big screen
AFP via Getty
13/37
Brexit Party leader, Nigel Farage arrives
Reuters
14/37
Brexit supporters gather
AP
15/37
Ann Widdecombe speaks to pro-Brexit supporters
PA
16/37
Brexit supporters wave Union flags as they watch the big screen
AFP via Getty
17/37
AFP via Getty
18/37
People wave British Union Jack flags as they celebrate
Reuters
19/37
Pro-Brexit demonstrators celebrate on Parliament Square on Brexit day
Reuters
20/37
A pro-Brexit supporter jumps on an EU flag
PA
21/37
Getty
22/37
AFP via Getty
23/37
PA
24/37
Getty
25/37
AP
26/37
Getty
27/37
A man waves Union flags from a small car as he drives past Brexit supporters gathering
AFP via Getty
28/37
A pro-Brexit supporter pours beer onto an EU flag
PA
29/37
Getty
30/37
An EU flag lies trampled in the mud
Getty
31/37
Getty
32/37
PA
33/37
PA
34/37
Getty
35/37
Getty
36/37
PA
37/37
AFP via Getty
1/37
Pro-Brexit supporters celebrating in Parliament Square, after the UK left the European Union on 31 January. Ending 47 years of membership
PA
2/37
Big Ben, shows the hands at eleven o’clock at night
AFP via Getty
3/37
Pro Brexit supporters attend the Brexit Day Celebration Party hosted by Leave Means Leave
Getty
4/37
Brexit Party leader Nigel Farage smiles on stage
AFP/Getty
5/37
People celebrate in Parliament Square
Reuters
6/37
A Brexit supporter celebrates during a rally in Parliament square
AP
7/37
Police form a line at Parliament Square to prevent a small group of anti-Brexit protestors from going through to the main Brexit rally
PA
8/37
Nigel Farage speaks to pro-Brexit supporters
PA
9/37
PA
10/37
JD Wetherspoon Chairman Tim Martin speaks as people wave flags
Reuters
11/37
Getty
12/37
Brexit supporters wave Union flags as they watch the big screen
AFP via Getty
13/37
Brexit Party leader, Nigel Farage arrives
Reuters
14/37
Brexit supporters gather
AP
15/37
Ann Widdecombe speaks to pro-Brexit supporters
PA
16/37
Brexit supporters wave Union flags as they watch the big screen
AFP via Getty
17/37
AFP via Getty
18/37
People wave British Union Jack flags as they celebrate
Reuters
19/37
Pro-Brexit demonstrators celebrate on Parliament Square on Brexit day
Reuters
20/37
A pro-Brexit supporter jumps on an EU flag
PA
21/37
Getty
22/37
AFP via Getty
23/37
PA
24/37
Getty
25/37
AP
26/37
Getty
27/37
A man waves Union flags from a small car as he drives past Brexit supporters gathering
AFP via Getty
28/37
A pro-Brexit supporter pours beer onto an EU flag
PA
29/37
Getty
30/37
An EU flag lies trampled in the mud
Getty
31/37
Getty
32/37
PA
33/37
PA
34/37
Getty
35/37
Getty
36/37
PA
37/37
AFP via Getty
“As the UK police lead on international criminality says, ending the transition period without a good deal on security would severely damage Britain’s ability to catch criminals who flee.
“The UK has made over a thousand arrests in the last decade using the European Arrest Warrant, while Interpol and the European Criminal Record Data Exchange have also been critical.
“Without these invaluable tools, Brits will be more vulnerable in 2021 and beyond.”